[ixpmanager] AS-SET Is not Working

[Nick Hilliard (INEX)]

Shahab Vahabzadeh wrote on 18/04/2020 10:32:
> I have a customer (AS16322) and AS-PARSONLINE-PEERS is set for them.
> And route server configuration I see this line:
> 
>      allas = [ 16322, 35615, 39571, 41061, 44243, 51618, 56547, 57574, 
> 60315, 60512,
>                60605, 60811, 60976, 61250, 62039, 62367, 200312, 202571, 
> 204781, 204812,
>                205550, 205837, 206862
>      ];
> 
> Which all is taken from AS-SET, but when I am checking their advertised 
> routes in:
> 
> http://members.tehran-ix.ir/lg/rs1-ipv4/routes/protocol/pb_as16322_vli22_ipv4
> 
> Most of the routes are filteredI checked some of them, both AS-SET and 
> Route Objects are correct in Ripe, Like this:
> 
> 109.206.252.0/22 <http://109.206.252.0/22>
> AS Path: 16322 60976 25264 25264 25264 25264
> 
> In Ripe Database, There is Route Object for 109.206.252.0/22 
> <http://109.206.252.0/22> with AS25264 and in AS-SET I can find AS60976 
> as AS16322 customer.
> 
> So what is wrong? Why Its working good?

This is working correctly.  The routes are being filtered because the 
origin AS is not included in the AS-SET.  I.e. AS-PARSONLINE-PEERS does 
not include AS25264 (or 48551 or 60631)

The AS-SET that you're using here needs to include all of Pars Online's 
customers.  Maybe this is the wrong AS-SET to use?

The aut-num object for Pars Online suggests that AS60976 provides 
transit for a lot of other ASNs. This means that they probably need to 
create an as-set for their customers instead of for their peers.

Nick